By Mary Beth West, APR
Holy tofu and organic black beans, Batman – The Tomato Head is leaving Downtown Maryville!
The announcement of The Tomato Head’s Maryville closure in favor of plans to build a West Knoxville location at the Gallery Shopping Center hit all-things-social last night, and, to say the least – the Maryville Tomato Head faithful are none-too-happy. Some of the comments via FB and the News Sentinel website (apart from the “Yeah Baby!”s of our West Knoxville friends):
- “Maryville has completely supported TH, and their presence has helped jumpstart revitalization in downtown Maryville. Notice they didn’t say they were losing money (the restaurant is always busy). I will drive past the Gallery, and I will take out-of-town guests to Cafe 4 and Latitude 35 on Market Square. The whole vibe of TH can now be transferred to a suburban sprawl location. Maybe their ‘unattainable’ 3rd location could open at Turkey Creek? They can close the Market Square location when space becomes available in Farragut.”
- “Really disappointed in @thetomatohead decision. Quite illogical. I’ve eaten my last meal there.”
- “This is not right!! I cannot imagine that this location hasn’t been successful. . . .what a crock. Seriously.”
- “Crazy. I’ll not be back.”
And my personal favorite:
- “Booooooooooo!!!”
In this economy, The Tomato Head’s visionary founder, Mahasti Vafaie, and business partner Scott Partin have achieved a brand with legions of followers in both the Knoxville and Maryville downtowns. Great atmosphere. Great vibe. And absolutely delightful food.
On the one hand, it’s an enviable position for any brand to have such a fan base that an announcement like this one evokes such a strong reaction (West Knoxville: “Yayyyyyy!”; Blount County: “Doh!”).
What’s unenviable: the backlash itself. And for The Tomato Head, they’re about to get backlash-whiplash from Blount County in a big way, I fear.
As a business owner, I understand and fully respect that many valid factors can play into a company’s unpopular decisions, made for the greater long-term good of the business.
However, as I put on my public relations hat (and let’s face it, it’s always on), I have to question whether The Tomato Head’s handling of this announcement – and of course, the very decision itself – presents far more damage to the brand in a significant enough geographic area to nullify the gains of greener pastures elsewhere.
I have a lot of West Knoxville friends. Love ‘em. But as a Blount Countian, it’s more than a bit irksome watching some of them take that deeply inhaled drag from the stogie of geo-economic superiority here. They’re sympathetically patting us Maryville folk on the back at our culinary loss, then two seconds later gently closing the door and breaking out into a full-on Church Lady Superior Dance (and I don’t mind aging myself with that comment; it’s gotta be said).
A few tips for companies considering a controversial decision:
- Don’t take your fan base for granted when making decisions that are personal to those fans. For The Tomato Head, it’s not just that they’re politely asking their Blount County diners simply to drive across the river to West or Downtown Knoxville instead. The exodus feels far more personal than that. And what’s more, in the initial news reports, The Tomato Head apparently isn’t politely asking their Blount patrons for anything. They didn’t express anything to Maryville verbally – only through its actions of abruptly leaving. (Note: a Facebook post by TH in recent hours explains the decision and shares stronger personal sentiments about the departure, but one wonders if it’s coming too late.)
- If the tough decision must be made, put thought into how it’s announced by anticipating the feelings it will elicit and demonstrating some level of sensitivity toward those impacted. It probably would have been far less damaging to The Tomato Head in Blount County if the Downtown Maryville closure had been announced prior to any mention being made of the West Knox plans. Yes, there still would have been deep disappointment about the loss, but at least there wouldn’t have been the feelings of an overt snub factor involved.
As for myself, I wish The Tomato Head well, and I’m going to miss their presence, their people, and most especially, their southwestern salad with organic blue corn chips and southwest vinaigrette. I’m also going to miss what they brought to our Downtown and the way Maryville felt about the people in that nice yellow building on West Broadway.




![MC900234312[1]](http://marybethwest.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2012/04/MC9002343121.jpg)

![MC900034335[1]](http://marybethwest.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2012/03/MC9000343351-150x150.jpg)
![MC900432691[1]](http://marybethwest.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2012/02/MC9004326911.png)
![MC900335717[1]](http://marybethwest.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2012/02/MC9003357171-150x150.jpg)

